I Should Have Been a Criminal

When Deeply Held Beliefs Break Against Reality

On the Fourth of July, we celebrate liberty. We light fireworks for freedom.
We sing songs of justice. And somewhere beneath it all, we still say the words: “With liberty and justice for all.”

I used to believe those words. As a child, I stood straight and recited them with hand over heart—believing in the promise they held. I believed in the courtroom dramas and investigations of my youth—Perry Mason, Matlock, Columbo—where evidence mattered, where truth was pursued, where justice prevailed.

Then I found myself sitting in a windowless courtroom beneath a hospital, and something I had believed about rights collided with reality.

Had I been accused of a crime, an entire framework of familiar protections would have surrounded the accusation. I would have had the right to know the charges against me, to see and challenge evidence, to confront witnesses, to participate in my defense, and, within constitutional limits, to represent myself.

But I had committed no crime. I was inside the civil commitment system.

Civil commitment is not criminal prosecution, and its legal purpose is different. Yet the state can still exercise extraordinary power over a person through it—taking liberty, restricting autonomy, and under separate proceedings potentially authorizing treatment the person does not want.

It was here that I encountered a paradox I had never imagined: A person does not need to have committed a crime for the government to exercise some of its most profound powers over their liberty and body.

The Shiny Illusion of Rights

Rights look reassuring on paper. Statutes describe procedures. Constitutions promise due process. Patient-rights documents describe protections. Attorneys are appointed. Hearings are held. Forms are completed. But a right written on a page and a right a person can meaningfully exercise are not necessarily the same thing. That distinction changed the way I understood law.

The question is not simply whether a right exists. The question is whether the person whose liberty is at stake can actually use it. Can they see the information being used to make decisions about them? Can they meaningfully challenge it? Can they bring forward contrary information? Can they call witnesses? Can they speak? Can they participate in decisions about their own representation? And what happens when the person says that the story being presented about them is simply not true?

These questions become particularly difficult in psychiatry because disagreement itself can acquire clinical meaning. Once a person has been placed within a psychiatric story, their efforts to contradict it may be interpreted through that same story.

The very act of saying this is not who I am can lose the ordinary meaning it would possess almost anywhere else.

That is an extraordinary position for any human being to occupy.

What Does a Right Mean If It Cannot Be Exercised?

The deeper issue is not whether criminal law and civil commitment should be identical. They should not. They arise from different legal purposes and different bodies of law. The comparison matters because liberty matters in both. So does bodily autonomy. So does access to the information being used against a person. So does meaningful representation. So does the ability to challenge a story carrying the power of the state.

When we create a legal process capable of taking something as fundamental as liberty without an allegation of criminal wrongdoing, the safeguards surrounding that power should matter enormously—not merely in statute, but in practice.

A checkbox is not due process simply because the form contains the right words. A hearing is not necessarily meaningful merely because one occurred. Representation cannot be measured solely by whether an attorney's name appears on the page. The responsibility embodied in the safeguard is what matters.

I Should Have Been a Criminal

The title is intentionally unsettling. I did not want to be a criminal. I had committed no crime.

What stunned me was discovering that had I been accused of one, many of the protections I had spent my life associating with American justice would have been immediately recognizable. Instead, I entered a different legal world—one most people know almost nothing about until they or someone they love suddenly finds themselves inside it.

That experience left me with a question I still believe deserves serious consideration:

When government has the power to take the liberty and bodily autonomy of someone who has committed no crime, shouldn't the protections surrounding that power be among the strongest we have?

Perhaps that is the deeper meaning hidden inside the provocative title.

I should not have needed to be a criminal for my voice, my rights, and my liberty to matter.

Previous
Previous

The Call to Grieve: On Grief, Anger & Betrayal

Next
Next

Part 2: Unmasking the Diagnosis, Reclaiming the Child