There is a myth so deeply woven into the fabric of our culture that most don’t recognize it as myth at all. It tells us that to be wise, we must be unemotional. That to be credible, we must be detached. That the ideal human is the “objective observer”—rational, separate, unaffected.
This worldview is not ancient or timeless. It was born just over 400 years ago, during the scientific revolution—a period that gave us extraordinary new ways to understand the universe, but also strengthened a mechanistic way of seeing: mind separated from body, human from nature, observer from observed.
Yet science itself moved on.
As Charlene Spretnak writes:
“All of reality is relational. I was puzzled—still am—by the fact that it took only about 100 years for the mechanistic worldview to spread through nearly all social institutions and systems of knowledge … yet it has now been more than 100 years since Einstein’s first two articles established that the universe is best understood as highly relational, rather than mechanistic. Our hypermodern societies currently possess only a kindergarten-level understanding of the deeply relational nature of reality.”
— Charlene Spretnak, Relational Reality (2011, p. 5)
And yet the mechanistic, non-relational worldview remains deeply embedded in our institutions. We see it in legal systems, medical models, educational frameworks, and corporate hierarchies. Even some spiritual paths subtly perpetuate it, praising transcendence over embodiment, “light” over the honest complexity of human feeling.
Perhaps one of its most enduring legacies is the ideal of objectivity itself—the belief that the observer can somehow stand outside what is being observed, untouched by history, assumptions, emotions, relationships, and the very act of observing.
Cyberneticist Heinz von Foerster called objectivity a Western “peculiar delusion and cognitive blind spot.” Second-order cybernetics went further, placing the observer back inside the system being observed. We are participants in the worlds we describe, not disembodied eyes hovering somewhere beyond them.
So much of our pain can arise from this disconnection—from being taught to stand apart from life rather than fully within it.
What happens when you feel deeply in a world that prizes detachment? You may be called unstable, dramatic, irrational, overly sensitive—or ill. When the soul stirs with grief or longing, when the heart breaks open in protest of injustice or personal loss, the experience may be treated as a problem to eliminate rather than something asking to be understood.
And this is where worldview matters.
Experiences interpreted through one framework as psychiatric symptoms may be understood very differently within spiritual, cultural, and Indigenous traditions—as a shamanic crisis, a dark night of the soul, a spiritual emergence, or a threshold experience.
The experience has not necessarily changed. The story through which we understand it has.
And yet, too often, instead of becoming curious about what an experience means, we try to silence its expression.
Here is the invitation: when resistance arises—whether in the body, mind, or emotions—don't immediately push it away or assume something is wrong. Get curious.
Resistance can be an edge of transformation—the place where an old way of seeing no longer quite holds and something new is trying to emerge.
As long as we cling to the myth of separation, we may miss the sacred within our own discomfort.
But if we allow ourselves to feel, to stay with the tension, to listen to the stirrings within, something astonishing can begin to unfold.
A doorway opens.
Not into madness.
But into wisdom.
References
Spretnak, C. (2011). Relational reality: New discoveries of interrelatedness that are transforming the modern world. Green Horizon Books.
von Foerster, H. (1979). Cybernetics of cybernetics. In K. Krippendorff (Ed.), Communication and control in society (pp. 5–8). Gordon and Breach.
Glanville, R. (1995). Chasing the blame. In G. Lasker (Ed.), Research on progress: Advances in interdisciplinary studies on systems research and cybernetics (Vol. 11). IIASSRC.
Photo Credit: Houcine Ncib-Unsplash