Beneath the white coats and credentials echoes something far older than science:
the ancient story that women are simply too much. They feel too deeply. Speak too boldly. Grieve too openly. Rage when something is wrong. Their ways may be unusual, intuitive, attuned to nature, sensing what others cannot. They do not always fit neatly within the boundaries drawn for them.
Across history, women who fell outside accepted boundaries have been called witches, hysterics, immoral, unstable, disordered—something to be feared, corrected, controlled, or explained away. Named. Boxed. Bound. Contained.
And so, for centuries, the feminine has repeatedly been framed as frailty. Women's emotions have been transformed into disorders, grief into illness, righteous rage into symptoms.
They once called it hysteria—its very name derived from the Greek word for uterus, carrying forward an ancient association between women's reproductive bodies and supposed mental instability. The language has changed. The question of who gets to define normality has not.
Today the names include depression, anxiety, borderline personality disorder, and ADHD. These diagnoses are not interchangeable with the old diagnosis of hysteria, nor is every woman who receives one wrongly diagnosed. But history should make us willing to ask a difficult question:
When is a diagnosis describing suffering—and when is it defining as pathology a woman's response to the conditions of her life?
Who Defines Madness?
Behind much of modern psychiatric diagnosis lies the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders—the DSM—published by the American Psychiatric Association.
First published in 1952, the manual has undergone repeated revision and enormous expansion. Its diagnostic categories and criteria now reach deeply into medicine, insurance, schools, disability determinations, research, institutions, courts, and the ways people come to understand themselves.
Yet psychiatric diagnoses are not discovered in the same way we discover a bacterium, identify a tumor, or measure blood glucose. Committees review research, debate definitions and thresholds, establish criteria, and determine which categories will be included, revised, renamed, combined, or removed.
Psychologist Paula Caplan knew this process from the inside. Caplan had taught the DSM believing it to be scientifically grounded. In 1988, she accepted an invitation to serve on two DSM-IV committees. After seeing the process from within, she later wrote:
“I was shocked to learn that the ways that ‘abnormality’ and its varieties were chosen and described within the manual were extremely far from scientific.”
Caplan ultimately resigned from the DSM-IV process on what she described as moral, ethical, and professional grounds. Her experience became part of the foundation for They Say You're Crazy: How the World's Most Powerful Psychiatrists Decide Who's Normal. And the title itself asks the question at the heart of this essay:
Who gets to decide who is normal?
So when we ask what counts as madness, we also have to ask:
Who's doing the counting?
Women and the Diagnostic Gaze
Women have long occupied a peculiar place within psychiatric history. Their reproductive bodies, sexuality, grief, anger, motherhood, refusal of prescribed roles, and departures from cultural expectations have repeatedly been interpreted through medical and psychiatric frameworks. The terminology changes. The cultural assumptions do not necessarily disappear with it.
Psychiatrist and historian Jonathan Metzl, in Prozac on the Couch: Prescribing Gender in the Era of Wonder Drugs, traced this pattern through the histories of Miltown, Valium, and Prozac. His examples are extraordinary.
He documents a 1956 Cosmopolitan discussion of tranquilizers being used to “cure” frigid women. He examines a 1970s psychiatric advertisement introducing a lesbian woman who “needs” Valium to find a man. And he traces the gendered narratives that continued into the Prozac era. The medicine changed. The language of psychiatry changed. The story of the woman who needed changing did not necessarily disappear with them.
Metzl's work asks us to notice something important: psychiatry's movement toward biological explanations did not automatically erase the cultural assumptions about gender embedded in earlier psychiatric thought.
Old stories can survive inside new language.
When Distress Becomes Diagnosis—and Diagnosis Becomes a Prescription
Women remain substantially more likely than men to use antidepressant medication. That disparity deserves more than a passing explanation, because women's suffering does not occur outside the conditions of women's lives.
Women carry caregiving responsibilities, poverty and economic insecurity, violence and sexual abuse, discrimination, motherhood, hormonal transitions, relationship loss, isolation, exhaustion, and the often invisible expectation that they will continue caring for everyone around them while asking very little for themselves.
But women are not interchangeable, and neither are our responses to what life brings. The same experience may move through two women very differently. What overwhelms one person may be carried differently by another, shaped by temperament, history, sensitivity, relationships, resources, meaning, previous experience, and the particular capacities each person brings to the moment. Research on resilience has increasingly confirmed what life itself teaches us: there is no single human response to adversity, nor one simple measure of what another person “should” be able to bear.
I explore this more deeply in What Can a Human Heart Hold?, an inquiry into resilience, sensitivity, and the different capacities with which human beings meet adversity.
So when grief, fear, exhaustion, anger, despair, sleeplessness, or an inability to continue functioning as before arise, we should not assume that either the experience or the response tells us that something within the woman is diseased. Instead, we might ask:
Where does the disorder reside—in the woman, or in the conditions to which she is responding?
And before calling the problem psychiatric, what has actually been investigated? Hormonal and thyroid changes, nutritional deficiencies, autoimmune and other physical conditions, sleep deprivation, medication effects, chronic stress, trauma, violence, grief, environmental exposures, and the cumulative demands placed upon the body can all matter. A woman is not a mind floating separately from her body, her relationships, her history, or the world in which she lives.
Yet the pharmaceutical industry has long understood how to speak to women's distress. From tranquilizer advertising in the mid-twentieth century through the antidepressant era, women have repeatedly appeared in stories promising relief from anxiety, dissatisfaction, exhaustion, and emotional pain. The cultural message beneath the advertising has often been remarkably familiar: calm down, cope better, return to functioning, feel like yourself again.
But when distress is first translated into psychiatric diagnosis and diagnosis then becomes a prescription, something important can disappear from view: What happened to her?
The prescription itself can reinforce a powerful story: the problem resides within you, and the drug is there to correct it. Yet changing a person's thoughts, feelings, energy, sleep, or behavior with a psychoactive substance does not tell us what caused her suffering in the first place. Nor does a response to a drug establish that an underlying psychiatric disease has been identified or corrected.
And the drugs themselves are not without consequence. Depending upon the medication and the person taking it, psychiatric drugs can produce significant adverse effects—including sexual dysfunction, emotional blunting, agitation or sedation, sleep disruption, weight and metabolic changes, cognitive effects, movement disorders, and withdrawal symptoms that can become severe for some people. These effects matter, particularly when a woman has been told that the problem lies within her rather than being given a fuller understanding of what the drug does, what is known and unknown, what alternatives exist, and what may happen if she later chooses to stop taking it.
That is an issue of informed consent and bodily autonomy.
Medication may alter the expression of suffering. But it cannot tell us what the suffering means or where it began. It cannot determine whether a woman's despair arose from grief, violence, exhaustion, hormonal or physical changes, nutritional depletion, trauma, relationship, isolation, overwhelming circumstances, spiritual crisis, or some combination of forces that has pushed the whole being out of alignment.
And sometimes what has been named a symptom may contain information we desperately need to hear.
What if her sadness is sacred? What if her rage is righteous?
What if, instead of immediately asking how to make the feeling disappear, we first asked what it has come to tell us?
What If the Woman Is Responding to the World?
This is why the work of feminist psychologist Jane M. Ussher matters.
In The Madness of Women: Myth and Experience, Ussher examines the history of women's madness, the incarceration and regulation of women considered difficult or deviant, and the ways depression, premenstrual distress, and borderline personality disorder have been constructed and understood.
Rather than automatically locating the source of women's suffering inside the individual woman, Ussher asks us to look at the social, relational, material, and cultural conditions surrounding her.
She describes the possibility of understanding women's distress as: “a reasonable response, rather than a reflection of pathology within.” That distinction changes the question completely. Instead of immediately asking: What is wrong with her? we might first ask: What happened to her? What is she carrying? What has her body endured? What conditions surround her? What has she been expected to tolerate? What is her anger telling us?What needs to change around her—not merely within her?
Women's distress is real. Taking its context seriously does not diminish suffering. It takes suffering seriously enough to ask where it came from.
The Feminine Was Never the Disease
The suffering can be very real. The grief can be overwhelming. Anxiety can be terrifying. A person can become profoundly disoriented, unable to sleep, unable to function, or experience states of consciousness that neither they nor the people around them understand. But suffering is not synonymous with mental illness. That distinction matters.
Before locating the problem inside a supposedly disordered mind, we should be asking far more fundamental questions. What has happened to this person? What has her body endured? Has there been trauma, violence, grief, chronic stress, isolation, sleep deprivation, nutritional depletion, hormonal or thyroid dysfunction, medication or drug effects, environmental exposure, or another physical condition? What is happening in her relationships and circumstances? What meaning does she herself give to what she is experiencing? Has something pushed the whole being profoundly out of alignment?
A diagnostic label can name a collection of experiences and behaviors. Naming the pattern does not, by itself, establish what caused it. And that is precisely why context matters. History matters. The body matters. Trauma matters. Relationship matters. Environment matters. Spirit matters. Power matters. Gender matters. Culture matters.
And who possesses the authority to define another human being matters.
For centuries women have been told, in different languages, that they are too emotional, too intuitive, too sexual, not sexual enough, too angry, too unruly, too sensitive, too mystical, too loud, too difficult. Too much. Perhaps the question was never whether women were too much.
Perhaps the world we built became too small to hold the fullness of the feminine.
There is nothing mad about a woman who refuses to be broken by the weight of a world that pathologizes her soul. You are not broken or sick. Do not let them tell you otherwise.
Her grief may have something to say.
Her anger may know where the boundary was crossed.
Her body may be telling us what has not yet been investigated.
Her spirit may be calling her back into alignment.
Her voice may be the beginning of her return.
Before we name her, perhaps we should listen.
References
Caplan, P. J. (1995). They Say You're Crazy: How the World's Most Powerful Psychiatrists Decide Who's Normal.
Metzl, J. M. (2003). Prozac on the Couch: Prescribing Gender in the Era of Wonder Drugs. Duke University Press.
Ussher, J. M. (2011). The Madness of Women: Myth and Experience. Routledge.
Photo Credit: Matthew Henry-Unsplash