The Power of Lies, The Cost of Truth.

There was a time when I believed I knew my path. It stretched out before me like a winding trail through the hills, clear and bright, leading me toward the life I thought was meant to be mine. Psychology. Psychiatry. The mind. The heart. A healer of the soul or so these names imply.

People found their way to me with their stories, their sorrows, their tangled thoughts, and I held space for them. What better calling than this? To sit with another human being and listen. To be the lighthouse when their waters turned rough.

I enjoyed my college studies delving into an expanded horizon of knowledge from around the world. But some of the most consequential learning came not in the classroom but in the fluorescent-lit halls of the Neuropsychiatric Institute at UCLA, where I became part of a research team interested in the ability of the mind to learn.

It was there that I first glimpsed something I could not unsee.

The Experimentation of Souls

The institute was at the forefront of something new in the early 70’s: the Violence Control Center, a government-funded project, presented as a way to understand, predict and control violent behavior.

My professor raised the alarm. He saw ethical boundaries being crossed in ways that deeply troubled him, and what I encountered troubled me as well. I had grown up in nature, surrounded by animals who were more family than pets, trekking through the wilderness where life pushed in pure, untamed beauty. The animal experimentation alone was more than I could stomach.

But the questions extended beyond animals to human beings and to the extraordinary power psychiatry was seeking over behavior itself. The language was treatment, research, prevention, progress. The mind, the soul, the very essence of a human being, reduced to something to be altered, subdued, controlled. So underneath all the fine words was one thing: control and the experimentation that came with it. When control becomes the goal, choice, agency, and humanity can become collateral damage.

So I walked away—from the research and from the world I had believed would be mine.

I thought I was done. But life has a way of leading you back to the very places you swore you would never return to.

The Circle of Voices

Not long after, my personal world changed in ways heretofore unseen.

My parents had been in a plane crash—one that, by all logic, they should not have survived. They had been flying over the vast, untamed landscapes of Southern Utah when the small plane went down. The wreckage should have been their grave. And yet, my mother walked—twelve miles through the wilderness, guided, she would later tell me, by something unseen. An angel’s hand on her shoulder. A presence leading her, step by step, to safety and help.

By some miracle, they all lived. And I drove across the desert with my grandmother and a friend from church to bring them home from the hospital, to see with my own eyes that they were still here, still breathing.

The experience had barely settled inside me when I found myself back in class. It was a course on Group Process Theory & Practice—one that encouraged us to share, to expose the raw, beating hearts of our personal lives so we could understand how to work with others in their vulnerability.

That day, we sat in a circle, waiting for our turn to speak. One by one, my classmates unfolded their struggles, their griefs. A girl, barely holding herself together, broke down as she spoke of her parents' divorce. The pain in her voice was real, tangible. The room held its breath with her sorrow.

I hesitated. The weight of my own story still pressed against my ribs, too fresh. Should I speak? Should I hold it inside?

In the end, I spoke. I told them. Of the crash. Of the impossible survival. Of the miles my mother walked through desolation, led by something unseen.

And then—the professor. She dismissed me, her words sharp and cutting. Accused me of fabricating a grander tragedy, as if grief were a competition, as if my truth had no place in the room. She had already decided what was real, what was acceptable, what fit within the tidy borders of her perception—and anything beyond that, anything that disrupted the narrative she had constructed, was simply not allowed to exist. This was the moment I learned what truth can cost. It is not always met with curiosity or understanding.

I stood there as the weight of her accusations pounded against me like stones, each word a strike meant to silence.

“I am not a liar,” I told her, my voice steady despite the storm inside me. “My parents were in a plane crash. I just brought them back from the hospital in Utah.”

And then I stood up and I walked out of that room the final piece that brought an end to my journey into a profession that was no longer a place I wanted to call home. I never went back.

The Other Side of the Table

I turned away from psychology and psychiatry believing I wanted no further part in a world where those entrusted with another person's vulnerability could respond with such certainty and so little curiosity.

And yet, years later, I was forced back into it—not as a practitioner, not as someone seeking help, but as a captive in its machinery.

I had not gone there seeking healing or psychiatric treatment. I was there because a system with the power to confine had placed me there, and once inside, I encountered from the other side many of the same questions about power, control, certainty, and the authority to define another person's reality that had troubled me decades earlier.

The system itself had not changed.

My story did not fit the one that had already been created about me, and once again I was told I was lying. The parallel was impossible to miss. Decades earlier, I had been free to stand up in that classroom, say “I am not a liar,” walk through the door, and never return. Inside the locked ward, I could still say the words. But I could not walk away.

That difference changed everything.

Full Circle

Life is strange. It loops back on itself in ways we can never predict or even imagine.

What I had witnessed decades earlier from the outside became even more apparent when I found myself caught inside its web. The circumstances were vastly different, but the underlying pattern was hauntingly familiar: someone with authority believed they knew more about the truth of another person's experience than the person actually living it.

At UCLA, I had begun questioning what happens when the desire to understand human beings becomes a desire to control them. In the classroom, I learned what it felt like to have something I knew to be true rejected because it fell outside another person's understanding of what was possible. And years later, inside the locked ward, I learned what happens when that same certainty is joined with institutional power and the person whose story is being rewritten cannot simply walk out the door.

Just because a story seems improbable does not mean it is untrue. It may simply exist beyond the limits of another person's experience or understanding. The danger begins when we become so certain of our own framework that curiosity disappears—and especially when professional authority gives that certainty the power to define another human being.

But there is another danger, one more subtle than simply refusing to listen.

We can listen and still not hear.

A person can be asked to tell their story and do so clearly, only to watch as the parts that do not fit the existing narrative are disregarded, reinterpreted, or left out altogether. The appearance of listening remains—the questions were asked, the interview occurred, the form was completed—but what the person actually said may have little effect on the story ultimately written about them.

That is not meaningful listening.

Listening requires more than receiving words. It requires allowing what we hear to have enough weight that it can challenge what we thought we already knew. It requires the possibility that another person's knowledge may correct our own understanding.

Perhaps this is what the circle ultimately taught me. Knowledge does not belong exclusively to those with credentials, titles, or institutional authority. Every person brings knowledge, wisdom, history, experience, and ways of knowing that deserve to be encountered rather than merely collected and then translated into someone else's framework.

Stories matter. Telling the truth matters. But being permitted to speak is not enough. What we say must be allowed to matter.

Otherwise, listening becomes another formality—a box checked before the authorized story continues on its way.

It is not the doctor who is essentially the active partner, but the patient. The doctor’s chief enemy is hubris. In every healing relationship there should come a strange turning point where the patient becomes the doctor and decides himself what to do with the doctor’s services and even whether he wants to accept them at all.

— Georg Groddeck, as cited in Rudnytsky & Charon (2008, p. 4)

Photo Credit: Priscilla DuPreez - Unsplash

Previous
Previous

Nourishing Your Second Brain: The Case for a Gluten-Free Lifestyle

Next
Next

Is a Label Defining Who You Are?