We often reach for a soft drink without thinking twice—whether it's to push through a long day, reward ourselves with a little sweetness, or simply out of habit. But beneath the fizzy surface is something worth examining much more carefully.
An occasional soda is one thing. When soda becomes something we drink every day—or replaces the water our bodies actually need—it is something else entirely.
I have seen the other end of this through years of healing work. I have watched people whose bodies were struggling begin to change when soft drinks were removed and water and nourishing food returned. When soda has become the primary—or nearly the only—source of fluid, I do not regard it as a harmless habit. The consequences can become profound.
One experience has never left me. A friend's son drank almost nothing but Mountain Dew. His health was deteriorating, and his doctors were struggling to understand what was happening. I urged his mother to get him off the soda. Her response was simple: “He's addicted to it.” He later died.
I cannot say that Mountain Dew caused his death; I do not have evidence that establishes that. But I have never forgotten the experience. It made the question of what we drink—and what happens when a highly sweetened, caffeinated beverage becomes something a person feels unable to stop consuming—anything but theoretical for me.
The Toll on the Body
Regular soft drinks are more than empty calories. Many contain enormous amounts of added sugar, usually in the form of high-fructose corn syrup or sucrose, often accompanied by caffeine, acids, flavorings, colors, and other additives.
Liquid sugar is particularly easy to consume in large amounts. Unlike whole fruit, soda delivers sugar without the fiber and food structure that help create fullness and slow consumption.
The evidence concerning habitual consumption of sugar-sweetened beverages is substantial. Higher consumption has been associated with weight gain, obesity, type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular disease, metabolic dysfunction, and fatty liver disease.
The liver deserves particular attention. Fructose is metabolized substantially in the liver, and high intake—particularly in the setting of excess calories—can contribute to the processes associated with non-alcoholic fatty liver disease. But perhaps the simplest question is this: What happens when we ask the body to process this day after day, year after year?
But What About Diet Soda? For years, the answer seemed obvious. Remove the sugar. Keep the sweetness. Problem solved. But nearly three decades after Robert Cohen published Diet Soda: The Deadly Poison, diet soda has not emerged as the uncomplicated healthy alternative its marketing once implied.
This does not mean every claim ever made about artificial sweeteners has been proven. It does mean that “zero calories” and “healthy” are not synonymous.
In 2023, the World Health Organization recommended against using non-sugar sweeteners as a long-term strategy for weight control or reducing the risk of chronic disease. Its review found no clear long-term benefit in reducing body fat and identified associations between higher long-term consumption and outcomes including type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular disease, and mortality.
Aspartame—the artificial sweetener found in many diet beverages—also came under renewed scrutiny that year. The International Agency for Research on Cancer classified it as “possibly carcinogenic to humans.” A separate WHO/FAO risk assessment maintained the existing acceptable daily intake because evidence concerning cancer risk at typical consumption levels remains limited. That distinction matters. It would be inaccurate to say that aspartame has been proven to cause cancer at ordinary dietary exposures. But it is equally inappropriate to translate “diet” or “zero” into good for you.
The Gut Is Listening Too
There is another dimension we understood far less well when the first warnings about diet soda appeared: the microbiome. Our digestive tract is inhabited by an enormous ecosystem of microorganisms involved in digestion, metabolism, immune function, and communication along the gut-brain axis.
Research is now investigating how non-sugar sweeteners interact with that ecosystem. A randomized human study published in Cell in 2022 examined saccharin, sucralose, aspartame, and stevia at doses below established acceptable daily intake levels. Researchers found changes in participants' microbiomes and metabolic profiles, with saccharin and sucralose significantly affecting glucose responses in the study groups.
Perhaps most interestingly, people did not respond identically. The effects varied according to the individual and their microbiome. Once again, the body refuses to behave like a standardized machine.
The Overlooked Effect on Mind, Mood, and Energy
The mind does not exist separately from the body. A heavily sweetened, caffeinated drink may provide a quick sense of energy or reward, but that experience does not necessarily last. Blood-glucose fluctuations, caffeine stimulation, disrupted sleep, habitual sweetness, and repeated cycles of craving can all affect how we feel.
Caffeine deserves particular attention for people who are sensitive to it. Excessive intake can contribute to jitteriness, anxiety, palpitations, sleep disturbance, and physical dependence. And poor sleep itself affects mood, concentration, appetite, energy, and our ability to meet the stresses of the following day.Again, bodies differ. Sensitivities differ. Amounts differ. That is why listening to your own body matters.
The Cycle of Addiction
There is a reason some people describe themselves as addicted to soda. Many popular soft drinks combine powerful reinforcers: intense sweetness, caffeine, reward, repetition, and habit.
Caffeine itself can produce physical dependence. When someone who regularly consumes substantial caffeine abruptly stops, headaches, fatigue, irritability, difficulty concentrating, and other withdrawal symptoms can follow. Then there is the ritual. The cold can in the afternoon. The fountain drink with lunch. The bottle beside the computer. The soda associated with comfort, energy, reward, or simply getting through the day.
Nancy Appleton and G. N. Jacobs address this directly in Killer Colas: The Hard Truth About Soft Drinks, examining the ways regular soda consumption can become deeply entrenched in everyday life.
So when someone says: “I know it's bad for me, but I can't stop,” perhaps we should listen rather than dismissing it as a lack of willpower. Because at that point, the question is no longer simply: Why are you drinking soda? It becomes: What keeps you reaching for it—and what will your body need in order to let it go?
Listening to the Body
The purpose of this conversation is not fear. It is awareness. How much soda are you actually drinking? Is it regular or diet? How much caffeine are you consuming? When do you reach for it? Are you thirsty—or tired?Are you seeking energy, comfort, sweetness, stimulation, or following a habit established years ago? What happens in your body afterward? And perhaps most importantly: What happens when you stop?
Our bodies are constantly communicating with us. Sometimes changing one seemingly small thing allows us to hear them again.
References & Further Reading
Appleton, N., & Jacobs, G. N. (2011). Killer Colas: The Hard Truth About Soft Drinks. Square One Publishers.
Cohen, R. (1998). Diet Soda: The Deadly Poison. Argus Publishing.
World Health Organization. (2023). Use of non-sugar sweeteners: WHO guideline.
International Agency for Research on Cancer & Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives. (2023). Aspartame hazard and risk assessment results released.
Suez, J., et al. (2022). Personalized microbiome-driven effects of non-nutritive sweeteners on human glucose tolerance. Cell, 185(18), 3307–3328.e19.