Leaving a Trail: Due Process, Gatekeepers, and the Human Lives that Pass Through Their Hands

Leaving a Trail

It dawned on me recently, while writing about Wendell Berry and reflecting on what we leave behind, that I have underestimated something about the work I have been doing for nearly twenty years.

For much of that time, I thought I was trying to find my way out—out of an unwarranted civil commitment, out of a story written about me that was not mine, out of records that did not reflect what actually happened, and eventually out of the legal consequences that continued long after I had walked through the doors of the hospital.

I was doing that. But somewhere along the way, something else happened.

I began leaving a trail.

I did not know who might someday need it. Perhaps it will be a woman sitting on the edge of a narrow hospital bed wondering how an ordinary day in her life ended behind a locked door. Perhaps it will be a man trying desperately to explain something that no one has bothered to investigate, slowly discovering that the more urgently he attempts to correct the story being created about him, the less credible those around him consider him to be. Perhaps it will be a family searching late into the night, trying to understand unfamiliar words—hold, petition, prepetition screening, examiner, capacity, commitment—while someone they love is being carried through a process none of them understands.

I hope the trail is also found by the people standing at the gates.

Because one of the most important things I learned is that an involuntary civil commitment does not happen in a single moment. A person moves through a succession of people, each of whom has been entrusted with a particular responsibility. A police officer stands at one gate. A physician stands at another. A prepetition screener stands at another. Psychiatrists, examiners, defense attorneys, county attorneys and, ultimately, a judge occupy other critical positions along the path.

We tend to call all of this the system, and certainly there is a system. There are institutional structures, professional cultures, statutory requirements, incentives, forms, established practices, relationships among agencies, and protections afforded to those acting within them. But speaking only of “the system” can obscure something essential: systems act through people, and people make choices.

A form does not check its own box. A report does not decide whether an allegation deserves investigation. A statute does not decide whether its requirements will be honored. A medical record does not write itself. Evidence does not decide whether it should be questioned. A lawyer decides whether to investigate and advocate. An examiner decides whether to independently assess what has been placed before them. A prosecutor decides what to put before the court. A judge decides whether the evidence and process are sufficient to justify exercising the extraordinary power of the state over another human being.

Those choices matter.

They matter because civil commitment law contains safeguards that are supposed to interrupt the movement toward confinement. In Minnesota, for example, the prepetition process requires more than the completion of paperwork. The statute examined in my dissertation required an interview, identification and investigation of the specific alleged conduct underlying the application, and exploration of alternatives to involuntary placement. Those are not ornamental words. They describe things a human being is supposed to do before another human being is pushed farther along the path.

The same is true of legal representation. The law requires counsel to consult with the person, have adequate time and access to records to prepare, continue representation through the proceedings, and act as a “vigorous advocate” on the person’s behalf. At the other end of the process, before commitment is ordered, the law requires clear and convincing evidence and specific findings establishing the requisites for commitment.

These requirements may look cumbersome to someone working within the process every day. Another interview. Another investigation. Another record to obtain. Another assertion to verify. Another opportunity to object. Another evidentiary requirement that must be satisfied before everyone can move on.

But that is precisely the point.

The Friction Is Intentional

Due process is not an inconvenience inserted into an otherwise efficient process. The friction is part of the protection.

When government is contemplating taking away someone’s liberty and potentially overriding bodily autonomy, the path is not supposed to be easy. It is supposed to require people to stop, look, listen, investigate, question and justify what they are about to do.

A healthy system should welcome those brakes.

Every person standing at one of those gates is part of the braking mechanism. The prepetition screener who discovers that an allegation does not withstand investigation is not obstructing the system. The examiner who reaches a conclusion different from the narrative already circulating is not causing a problem. The defense attorney who challenges unsupported assertions and insists upon evidence is not making everyone’s work more difficult. The judge who refuses to assume that everything upstream was performed correctly simply because official-looking documents have arrived in the courtroom is not interfering with the process.

That is the process working.

The danger arises when safeguards remain visible on paper but become formalities in practice. An investigation becomes a box checked. An interview becomes confirmation of a conclusion already reached. Independent examination becomes repetition of materials supplied by others. Advocacy becomes file management. Judicial scrutiny becomes reliance upon the understandable but dangerous assumption that everyone who came before must have done what the law required.

Then an error can begin to travel.

An uninvestigated statement becomes information in a report. The report is given to another professional, who assumes that the person who prepared it verified the underlying information. It reaches an examiner and acquires another layer of professional authority. It enters the courtroom. An attorney fails to challenge it. A judge sees the same information appearing in several places and may understandably believe that the apparent consistency represents corroboration.

But there is a profound difference between corroboration and repetition.

If everyone is drawing from the same unverified source, ten repetitions do not transform the original assertion into truth. Yet once the same story has traveled through enough official hands, the accumulation itself can begin to look like evidence.

That is why every gate matters.

Someone must be willing to look backward before sending the person forward. Someone must ask where the information originated, whether it was investigated, whether the person has seen what is being used against them, whether contradictory evidence exists, whether the statutory requirements were actually fulfilled, and whether the evidence really supports the action everyone is preparing to take.

Sometimes someone has to ask the simplest and most unsettling question of all:

What if this person is telling the truth?

My own experience taught me what happens when safeguards fail to stop a cascade. Years later, the Minnesota Ombudsman’s investigation approached the events in their totality rather than treating every participant’s action as an isolated event. The Ombudsman’s framework recognized the need for cross-collaboration and checks and balances so that a misstep in one part of a system does not lead to a cascade of events that no other part discovers or overcomes. The investigation of my case ultimately identified procedural missteps affecting the protections and due process that should have accompanied a proceeding involving liberty and a person’s future.

There is something deeply important in that word cascade. It explains why individual responsibility cannot disappear into an amorphous entity called “the system.” The structure may make error easier to propagate, but at every stage another human being encounters it. Each person has another opportunity to question it. Each person makes choices about what to accept, what to investigate, what to repeat and what to challenge.

A failure at the first gate therefore does not excuse a failure at the second. In fact, the existence of multiple gates is part of the protection. The next person is another opportunity to catch what the person before them missed.

That is what I wish every professional who participates in civil commitment understood in their bones. You are not simply responsible for completing your portion of a process. You are one of the human beings entrusted with ensuring that the process has a legitimate basis for continuing at all.

A Case to You. A Life to Me

There is another reason this matters.

For the professionals involved, the encounter may occupy an hour, a morning, a hearing, a report, a file on a desk, or one case among many that week. When their part is finished, they move on to the next person and the next responsibility.

The person does not.

For the professionals involved, mine was a case. For me, it was my life.

The consequences left the hospital and courthouse with me. I carried them into my work, my relationships, my finances, my reputation and my future. Sixteen years passed before a judge finally read documents including court transcripts of the hearings and then vacated the commitment and dismissed the petition. In the conclusion of my dissertation, I struggled with what it meant that something that should never have occurred could consume so much of a person’s life before being legally corrected.

That is why I am particularly interested in the lawyer who may someday find this trail.

Somewhere beneath the petition number is a human life. Before there was a respondent, there was a person. They had work that mattered to them, people who knew them, places where they belonged, things sitting unfinished on their desk, responsibilities awaiting their return, and a history that existed before anyone opened a file and began writing about them.

They had a name before the system gave them another one.

If you are the attorney appointed to stand beside them, you may be the last person in the room specifically charged with insisting that everyone else remember that. The words vigorous advocate are not decorative language tucked into a statute. They describe an obligation to another human being whose ability to protect themselves has been profoundly diminished by the very proceeding in which you now participate.

Read the records carefully. Ask the question that no one else has asked. Make the telephone call. Investigate the thing that does not make sense. Challenge the unsupported assertion. Find out where the information originated. Listen to your client long enough to understand what they are actually telling you. If something does not add up, do not assume that your client is the thing that does not add up.

The same appeal belongs to everyone else standing along the path. If you are the police officer, understand the significance of the gate at which you stand. If you are the prepetition screener, investigate because the person who comes after you may assume that you did. If you are the physician or psychiatrist, remember that your words may enter a courtroom carrying extraordinary authority. If you are an examiner, independence means more than reading what others have written. If you are a prosecutor, remember that the exercise of state power demands more than movement toward a desired outcome. And if you are the judge at the final gate, look backward. Ask whether the foundation beneath what has reached your courtroom is sound.

Someone upstream may have gotten something wrong.

You may be the first person who notices.

If you are, stopping the process is not a failure. Sending someone home who should never have been carried that far is not an embarrassment to the system. Correcting another professional’s error is not disloyalty to your colleagues.

It is integrity.

There are statutes. There are constitutional protections. There are rules, professional standards and procedures. They matter enormously. But none of them can climb out of a law book and protect the person whose liberty and bodily autonomy are at profound risk. People have to give those protections life.

The Squeaky Wheel

Over the years, I became the squeaky wheel—the person who kept returning with another document, another contradiction, another question that had never been answered. I was persistent because the consequences were persistent. What others could put back into a file cabinet remained attached to my life.

There is something revealing about the way institutions can respond to the squeaky wheel. Eventually, the sound itself can become the problem. The person who continues to raise the unresolved issue can be experienced as difficult, troublesome, excessive or simply unwilling to move on. Attention shifts subtly from what the person is saying to the fact that the person will not stop saying it.

Yet the squeak is information.

In any functioning system, friction, noise, resistance and unexpected feedback tell us where something may be wrong. We would think it absurd to silence a fire alarm because its sound was irritating while refusing to look for smoke. Yet human systems can do something remarkably similar when the person reporting the malfunction becomes less welcome than the malfunction itself.

I have come to understand my persistence differently because of that. I was not asking people to revisit something endlessly merely because I disliked its outcome. I was asking people entrusted with public and professional authority to look at what the record itself revealed, examine whether the safeguards had actually functioned and, when they had not, correct what followed.

That should not threaten a healthy institution. It should help one become healthier.

A system capable of self-correction needs its squeaky wheels. It needs the attorney who says the evidence is insufficient, the examiner whose conclusion disrupts the prevailing narrative, the employee who points out that a procedure was not followed, and the judge willing to look beneath what earlier decision-makers accepted. It also needs the person harmed by the process who refuses to disappear simply because her continued presence has become uncomfortable.

My dissertation ultimately concluded that without immediate feedback loops, there was essentially no mechanism for the system to self-correct before substantial damage occurred. I also documented what happened when I attempted to bring what I had learned back into that system: resistance, silence, and an extraordinary difficulty in getting institutions to examine what had gone wrong.

Perhaps, then, the question is not why the wheel keeps squeaking.

The question is why, after all this time, no one has fixed what is making it squeak.

Leaving the Markers

Perhaps that is why I kept everything I could gather.

Every document I preserved, every contradiction I marked, every transcript I obtained, every statute I read, every question I continued asking when people wished I would stop, and every piece of the story I refused to surrender became another marker on a path I did not yet realize I was building.

For years I believed I was gathering those things because I would someday need them to establish what had happened to me. I did need them. But now I wonder whether that was only part of their purpose.

Perhaps I was also gathering them for someone I will never meet.

I cannot go back and stand at those gates again. I cannot undo the choices other people made as I passed through them. But I can walk backward through what happened and leave markers where the path became dangerous. I can say: Look here. Ask this question. Request this document. Find out who supplied this information. Do not assume that because it has been repeated it was verified. Know what the law requires at this gate. Do not surrender your story.

And I can leave markers for the gatekeepers too.

When another human being reaches you, do not merely ask what you are supposed to do next. Ask whether that person should have reached you at all.

Look backward before you send them forward. Have enough independence to question the work of the person who came before you and enough humility to know that professional authority does not make any of us incapable of being wrong. If something is wrong, have the courage to become the place where the cascade ends.

This is the trail I now understand I have been leaving.

I hope no one ever needs it. But I know someone will.

And when that person comes this way, I want the path to be a little more visible than it was for me. I want there to be evidence that someone walked this terrain before them, learned where the ground gives way, and cared enough to leave markers behind.

Most of all, I hope that somewhere along that path there will be a police officer, a screener, a physician, a psychiatrist, an examiner, an attorney, a prosecutor or a judge who understands why the friction is there and chooses to become the safeguard they were entrusted to be.

Because what sits on your desk may be a file.

But what passes through your hands is a life.

Photo Credit: Luc Santeramo-Unsplash (A cairn marks the way for those who come after.)

Previous
Previous

Cybernetics: What the Heck is That?

Next
Next

Understanding Systemic Abuse