Understanding Systemic Abuse

Sometimes harm does not come from one person or one clearly identifiable act. It emerges through the accumulated actions of many people, policies, practices, and institutions. Each piece may appear reasonable when viewed alone. It is only when we step back and look at the whole that another picture emerges.

This is systemic abuse.

I first encountered language that helped me understand this phenomenon while researching my doctoral dissertation on the civil commitment process. Drawing on the work of Tim and Wendy Booth, I described systemic abuse as occurring when people’s problems are made worse by the very services intended to support them. It can include institutional attitudes, policies, and practices that harm people, damage family integrity, or infringe upon basic rights. Significantly, systemic abuse commonly arises through the actions of more than one person or agency. 

That last point is important because it helps explain why systemic abuse can be extraordinarily difficult to recognize—and even more difficult to correct.

Organizations divide responsibility. One person handles intake. Another evaluates. Another makes a recommendation. Someone else reviews the recommendation. Another person makes the final decision. Each may see only a small portion of what has happened.

The person experiencing the system, however, lives through all of it.

That creates a troubling paradox. The person with the most complete experiential knowledge of how the pieces interacted may also have the least institutional power to define what happened. Booth and Booth observed that sometimes only those affected can see the full picture, yet they may lack the power to speak out or find that, when they do, their voices go unheard. 

This is where systemic abuse differs from a simple mistake.

Mistakes happen in every human organization. Healthy systems expect them and create ways to discover and correct them. Systemic abuse becomes possible when harmful actions compound one another while the structure itself makes recognition, accountability, or correction difficult.

An inaccurate statement can enter a record. Someone else assumes it was verified. A third person repeats it. Eventually, repetition begins to look like corroboration. A person tries to correct the record but is dismissed because several professionals now appear to agree.

No single moment tells the whole story.

The pattern does.

This is why systems thinking became so important in my research. My dissertation examines systemic abuse through what Gregory Bateson called the “patterns that connect”—looking beyond isolated actions to the relationships among law, government, professional practice, institutional authority, and the person moving through them. 

The concept reaches far beyond civil commitment. Systemic abuse can potentially occur anywhere substantial power is exercised over people and responsibility is divided among institutions or professionals: health care, elder care, education, child protection, corrections, social services, workplaces, religious organizations, and legal systems.

One of the clearest indicators of an unhealthy system may be what happens after someone reports harm.

Does the institution become curious? Does someone step back and examine the whole sequence rather than defending an individual piece? Can information travel backward and produce correction? Are the people with power willing to discover that something they believed about their institution—or themselves—may have been wrong?

Or does the person raising the problem gradually become the problem?

That question matters because the inability to receive corrective feedback allows harmful patterns to perpetuate themselves. In my dissertation, I described the consequences of systems lacking meaningful feedback loops: problems become extraordinarily difficult to correct while protectionism and resistance help maintain an injurious status quo. 

Understanding systemic abuse therefore requires a different way of seeing. Instead of asking only whether each person performed a particular task, we have to ask what all of those actions created together.

And perhaps most importantly, when someone who has traveled through the entire system tells us that something is wrong, we need to resist the impulse to dismiss the voice because it is inconvenient.

Sometimes that person is the only one who has seen the whole.

Footnote

Minnesota provides an important example of why whole-system oversight matters. The Office of Ombudsman for Mental Health and Developmental Disabilities (OMHDD) is an independent state office whose statutory purpose includes promoting “the highest attainable standards of treatment, competence, efficiency, and justice” for persons receiving covered services. Minn. Stat. § 245.92. The Ombudsman is authorized to investigate the quality of services, examine whether state and county quality-assurance mechanisms adequately promote clients’ health, safety, and welfare, and analyze the actions of agencies, facilities, and programs where client rights may have been adversely affected. Minn. Stat. § 245.94, subd. 1. This broad oversight authority permits the Ombudsman to look across institutional and professional boundaries—to examine not simply an isolated act, but how separate actions interact and what they collectively produce. The OMHDD also accepts complaints involving both individual concerns and “system-wide” concerns.

Minnesota Statutes, Chapter 245 — OMHDD statutory authority

Minnesota Office of Ombudsman for Mental Health and Developmental Disabilities

Photo Credit: Dushyant Kumar-Unsplash

Previous
Previous

Leaving a Trail: Due Process, Gatekeepers, and the Human Lives that Pass Through Their Hands

Next
Next

What We Leave Behind: Remembering Wendell Berry