Why Is Change So Very Difficult—for Us and the Institutions We Inhabit?

How Our Ways of Knowing Shape What We Can Change

There is something both useful and dangerous about drawing a circle around a system and saying, This is what we are studying.

We could hardly make sense of the world without creating distinctions. We separate the cell from the body, the individual from the family, the organization from the community, and the institution from the larger culture in which it arose. We draw boundaries so that we can look more closely, name what we see, and organize complexity into something we can understand. The difficulty begins not when we draw these boundaries, but when we forget that we drew them.

Cybernetics has, in many ways, been a continuing effort to remember what earlier ways of seeing left outside the circle. Early cybernetics gave us extraordinarily useful ways of understanding communication, feedback, regulation, and control. Second-order cybernetics then complicated that picture by recognizing that the observer could not simply be removed from what was being observed. Whoever looks at a system brings language, expectations, history, training, categories, assumptions, and a particular location within the world.

Once the observer is placed back inside the picture, however, another question naturally emerges: What is the observer embedded within?

No observer exists alone. We belong to families, professions, institutions, communities, cultures, histories, and environments. We inherit languages, beliefs, and assumptions that we hold onto dearly, often without realizing how profoundly they shape what we are able to see. Those inherited ways of knowing influence what we recognize as normal, what we believe deserves explanation, what we accept as evidence, and what may remain almost invisible because it lies outside the framework through which we have learned to interpret the world.

This widening of the frame is one way of approaching what has sometimes been called third-order cybernetics. The term itself has been used in different ways, but the movement it points toward is important. Our attention shifts from a system being observed, and then from the observer participating in that system, toward the relationships among multiple observers and the larger social, cultural, institutional, and historical fields in which all of them participate.

The circle widens once again.

A physician and patient do not meet in an empty room. Years of professional education, previous medical experiences, institutional policies, economic pressures, family histories, scientific knowledge, cultural assumptions, and ideas about authority and care enter with them. A teacher and student bring far more into a classroom than curriculum. A judge and litigant encounter one another within histories of law, power, language, and institutional practice. Even an ordinary disagreement between two people rarely begins with the sentence that was just spoken. It may carry previous conversations, family patterns, inherited beliefs, unspoken fears, cultural meanings, and assumptions neither person realizes they have brought into the room.

The field is already there. Once we begin seeing in this way, relationship itself becomes part of what we are studying.

From Change to a Different Way of Knowing

Watzlawick, Weakland, and Fisch (1974) distinguished changes that occur within an existing system from those that alter the organization of the system itself. Keeney (1983) later described third-order change as something deeper still: an epistemological transformation, a change in the very way reality is known and constructed.

That distinction matters because a system can change its procedures while leaving the worldview beneath them almost untouched. An institution can create a new committee, revise a policy, introduce new technology, or move authority from one office to another while continuing to operate from the same assumptions.

The deeper shift occurs when the framework through which reality has been interpreted becomes visible—when what we had assumed simply was reality is recognized as one particular way of organizing it. That can be profoundly unsettling.

Robert Kegan (in Debold (2002)) has written about the emotional intensity involved in discovering that the way we have composed reality is not reality itself but a way of making sense of it. Bateson (2000) described related shifts as profound redefinitions of self, movements in which identity becomes less isolated and more deeply situated within relationship and ecology.

Pioneering psychiatrist and transpersonal psychologist Stanislav Grof's (1989) work on spiritual emergency belongs within this same larger conversation. Grof described profound experiences that may arrive unbidden, disrupting established identity and opening a person into a radically different relationship with self, meaning, consciousness, and the larger whole. Such experiences are not merely changes in opinion. They can alter the very structure through which experience is understood.

We are no longer rearranging furniture inside the same room. We begin to recognize that there may be other rooms. Perhaps even that the walls themselves were never quite where we thought they were.

Knowing in Relationship

When observers are understood as embedded within relationships and larger systems, knowledge begins to look different as well. Expertise remains important. There are things a physician knows that a patient does not, just as there are things an engineer, farmer, lawyer, carpenter, scientist, healer, or teacher knows because of years of disciplined study and practice. But expertise does not eliminate perspective.

Every form of knowledge illuminates some portion of the terrain while leaving something outside its field of vision. The farmer may know the land in ways the agricultural scientist does not. The scientist may understand processes invisible to the farmer. A community may recognize patterns unavailable to an administrator examining statistics from a distance. Someone living within a particular experience may know dimensions of that reality that cannot be accessed simply by observing from outside it.

The question is no longer which form of knowledge should defeat the others. The more interesting question becomes: What becomes possible when they are allowed to inform one another? This is where relational thinking becomes more than an ethical preference. It becomes a way of knowing. Listening is no longer simply good manners. It becomes a method of inquiry.

Dialogue is no longer merely a way to make people feel included. It becomes a means through which information unavailable to any single observer can enter the larger field. Difference becomes potentially valuable because another person may be standing where they can see something we cannot. A healthy system, therefore, is not simply one that gathers feedback. It must remain capable of being changed by what that feedback reveals.

Modern institutions have become remarkably good at collecting information. We survey, measure, audit, evaluate, organize stakeholder groups, solicit public comment, and gather enormous quantities of data. Yet a system can receive tremendous amounts of feedback while remaining essentially untouched by it. Information enters, but the assumptions beneath the system remain intact.

A relational approach asks whether those affected by the system possess any meaningful capacity to influence how that system understands itself. Participation alone is not enough.

A hospital can establish a patient advisory council while leaving fundamental power relationships unchanged. A government agency can hold public hearings after the essential architecture of a policy has already been determined. Organizations can create listening sessions, stakeholder committees, and community-engagement initiatives while carefully preserving the boundaries around what participants are actually allowed to change.

The language becomes participatory while the underlying structure remains hierarchical. The deeper test is whether what arises through relationship can alter the outcome.

When Knowing Changes, Power Changes

Perhaps the most consequential implication of relational knowing is that when we change who is permitted to know, we inevitably change who is permitted to hold power. This may be one of the deeper reasons change becomes so difficult.

Once the knowledge of the patient, resident, community member, worker, student, farmer, parent, or person living the consequences of a system is recognized as genuinely consequential, that person is no longer simply the recipient of someone else's expertise. They become a participant in defining reality.

The physician may still possess medical expertise, but no longer possesses the whole truth of the encounter. The planner may understand zoning, infrastructure, and technical requirements, but may not know the lived ecology of the place as those who inhabit it do. The policymaker may understand statutes and budgets while remaining far removed from the consequences of implementation. The scientist may understand measurable processes while another observer recognizes effects that have not yet entered the scientific frame.

None of this requires us to pretend that all knowledge is interchangeable. It requires us to recognize that legitimate knowledge may be distributed across the system. Once that happens, power can no longer rest as comfortably in one location.

This is where many institutions encounter their real difficulty. They can adopt the language of collaboration, lived experience, stakeholder engagement, co-creation, patient-centered care, community input, and participatory governance without changing who defines the problem, what counts as evidence, which questions are legitimate, or who ultimately decides.

One can invite someone into the room and still control the agenda. One can listen carefully and still retain exclusive authority to interpret what was said. One can collect feedback while deciding in advance which feedback will matter. One can call a process collaborative while preserving the underlying hierarchy almost perfectly.

Inclusion without a shift in epistemic power may simply become another way for the existing system to absorb dissent without changing itself. What looks like resistance to a new idea may therefore be resistance to the change in authority that the idea requires.

The Space In-Between

Perhaps the movement toward third-order thinking asks us to become more attentive to what happens in the space in-between. In my dissertation, I wrote that it is “at this juncture, and the space in-between, that the walls of our created constructs dissolve and new vistas emerge.” That remains one of the clearest ways I know to describe what relational knowing makes possible.

The space in-between is not empty. It is where disciplines meet, where assumptions become visible, where one person's knowledge encounters another's, and where patterns that cannot be seen from inside a single framework may begin to reveal themselves. It is also where the edges of our constructed categories become more obvious. Medicine meets law. Science meets lived experience. Institutional knowledge meets community memory. The individual meets the system. The human meets the more-than-human world.

None of these encounters requires us to abandon rigor. What they require is enough permeability for something larger than the original categories to become visible. Perhaps this is where genuinely new understanding emerges—not from the dominance of one perspective over another, but from the relational field created when the boundaries between them become permeable enough for something more to appear.

Collective Intelligence and the Larger Field

This is where the idea of collective intelligence becomes particularly important. A group may sometimes recognize what no individual member could see alone. A community may perceive patterns invisible within specialized silos. Different perspectives, when brought into genuine relationship rather than simply placed beside one another, can give rise to something that did not previously exist.

Knowledge can emerge between us. This possibility has profound implications because many of the problems confronting us cannot be contained within a single discipline or institution. Climate, public health, artificial intelligence, mental health, education, poverty, governance, ecological degradation, and social fragmentation cross the very boundaries through which our institutions have traditionally organized themselves. Yet our responses often remain fragmented.

Each discipline addresses the piece it recognizes. Each institution sees through its own mandate. Each profession protects its domain of expertise. The larger pattern may remain unseen precisely because no single observer stands far enough outside the whole to contain it. Perhaps no one can. Perhaps the whole must be approached relationally. That does not mean abandoning specialization. It means remembering that specialization is a lens, not the world.

Why Change Is So Difficult

Why, then, is change so very difficult—for us and for the institutions we inhabit?

Perhaps because deeper change asks more than the adoption of a new policy or practice. It may ask us to surrender certainty, question identities that have given us belonging, reconsider assumptions upon which careers and institutions have been built, and listen seriously to knowledge that does not fit comfortably within the stories through which we understand ourselves.

It may also require those who possess authority to share some portion of the power to define what is real, what matters, and what should happen next. That is where the difficulty often lies. The challenge is not only learning something new. It is becoming capable of being changed by what we learn.

Who Will Create What Comes Next?

Buckminster Fuller (in Vance & Deacon (1995)) repeatedly challenged people to stop devoting all of their energy to fighting systems that no longer worked and instead create alternatives capable of making old models obsolete.

It is an extraordinarily hopeful proposition. Yet it contains another question that may be even more important: Who will create what comes next? If new systems are designed through the same relationships of authority, separation, and exclusion that shaped the old ones, familiar structures may simply reappear beneath new terminology.

A genuinely relational system cannot merely have relational language attached to it. It must be created relationally.

That means bringing into the process not only recognized experts but also people who live within the consequences of the system. Lived experience would not replace expertise, but neither would it remain subordinate to it. Historical knowledge, embodied knowing, community memory, scientific knowledge, professional skill, cultural wisdom, and the lessons of previous failure could begin informing one another. The purpose would not be to pretend that all perspectives are identical or equally informed about every question. They are not. The purpose would be to recognize that no single perspective contains the whole.

That recognition requires humility, but it also expands intelligence. We become capable of seeing together what none of us could see alone.

Einstein (1946) once wrote that “a new type of thinking is essential if mankind is to survive and move toward higher levels.” Perhaps the movement toward a more relational understanding of systems is part of that new thinking. The task may not simply be to become better observers. It may be to recognize that we were never outside the system in the first place.

We are participants in relationships nested within relationships, systems within systems, and worlds within worlds. What we create changes the field in which others live, and their responses return to change us in turn. Once we begin to see that, the question is no longer simply how to design better systems. It becomes something more intimate and more demanding: How do we learn to participate differently in the systems we are continually creating together?

And perhaps the most difficult question of all: Are those who currently hold power willing to participate in creating systems in which power itself is held differently?

Joseph Jaworski has argued that, ultimately, “the only change that will make a difference is the transformation of the human heart.” That may be the deepest challenge of all. Systems do not transform simply because we redraw organizational charts, rewrite policies, or adopt a new vocabulary. They transform when the people who inhabit them begin to see, relate, listen, and exercise power differently.

Perhaps the transformation of our systems begins with the transformation of the relationships through which they are created—and, ultimately, with a change in the human heart.

References

Bateson, G. (2000). Steps to an ecology of mind: Collected essays in anthropology, psychiatry, evolution, and epistemology. University of Chicago Press. (Original work published 1972)

Debold, E. (2002, Fall–Winter). Epistemology, fourth-order consciousness, and the subject-object relationship. What Is Enlightenment, 22, 143–154.

Einstein, A. (1946, May 24). Telegram on behalf of the Emergency Committee of Atomic Scientists. Quoted in “Atomic Education Urged by Einstein,” The New York Times, May 25, 1946.

Grof, S., & Grof, C. (Eds.). (1989). Spiritual emergency: When personal transformation becomes a crisis. Penguin Putnam.

Keeney, B. P. (1983). Aesthetics of change. Guilford Press.

Mathon-Nerad, P. V. (2023). Separation from the real: The power of story at the heart of the civil commitment process[Doctoral dissertation, California Institute of Integral Studies].

Senge, P.M.,Scharmer, C.O., Jaworski, J. & Flowers, B.S. ( 2005). Presence: Exploring profound change in people, organizations, and society. Society for Organizational Change.

Vance, M. & Deacon, D. (1995). Think out of the box. Career Press.

Varela, F. J. (1976, Fall). Not one, not two. The CoEvolution Quarterly, 12, 62–67.

Watzlawick, P., Weakland, J., & Fisch, R. (1974). Change: Principles of problem formation and problem resolution. W. W. Norton.

Photo Credit: Jay Miller-Unsplash

Previous
Previous

Water: The Untold Battle for the Resource of All Life

Next
Next

The War of Paradigms