Lately, I’ve been spending time puttering around my garden. The weather has been incredible, inviting me outside to shake off the last remnants of winter and breathe in the intoxicating scents of the season’s first roses and lilacs in full bloom. Those fragrances alone can make you giddy with delight, lost in serious daydreaming.
For me, a garden is a sacred space—one of peace, alignment, and refuge from a world that often feels unhinged. Here, life thrives abundantly. Bees hum, butterflies flutter, birds weave nests in hidden corners, and as twilight descends, fireflies emerge, turning the garden into a luminous, enchanted realm. In these moments, the world feels whole again.
Perhaps that is because nature continually reminds me of something we humans have a tendency to forget. Life does not organize itself into the neat boxes through which we have learned to understand it.
Everything in the garden exists in relationship with something else. Soil, water, fungi, insects, birds, plants, sunlight, weather, decomposition, and regeneration participate in a living whole. Nothing survives entirely unto itself. And yet so much of the human world has been constructed differently.
We divide knowledge into disciplines. We separate mind from body, reason from emotion, human beings from nature, and one profession from another. We create categories and definitions that help us organize an extraordinarily complex world. Then, sometimes, we forget that we created them.
For every system there is an environment, which can (if we so decide) be looked at as a larger whole where the initial system participates. Since it would be impractical to do this at all times, we often chop out our system of interest, and put all the rest in the background as ‘environment’ … To do this on purpose is quite useful; to forget that we did so is quite dangerous.” — Francisco Varela (1976, p. 64)
The box becomes reality. And perhaps, without recognizing it, our hearts and minds become caged within it.
The Invisible Cage
Our beliefs shape how we perceive the world, and many of the beliefs through which we live are so familiar that we no longer recognize them as beliefs at all.
We inherit them from family, culture, education, religion, science, professional training, media, and the institutions surrounding us. They tell us what counts as knowledge, whom we should trust, what is normal, what is possible, and what should be dismissed.
Hofer and Pintrich's work on personal epistemology explored how our beliefs about knowledge and knowing develop and become increasingly complex. We may begin by imagining knowledge as something certain, possessed by authorities who provide the correct answers. Over time, we can develop a more contextual understanding in which knowledge requires evaluation, interpretation, evidence, perspective, and an awareness of the conditions in which knowing occurs.
But development is not automatic. Individuals can remain tightly attached to certainty. So can professions. So can entire institutions. The difficulty begins when a particular way of understanding the world ceases to recognize itself as a perspective and begins behaving as though it is simply the way the world is.
Philosopher and social critic Lewis R. Gordon describes this danger particularly well when he writes that disciplines can:
“lose sight of themselves as efforts to understand the world and have collapsed into the hubris of asserting themselves as the world … Practitioners delude themselves that the elimination of opposition, the eradication of an outside world, is the achievement of epistemic immortality.”
— Lewis R. Gordon (2006, p. 8)
That is a very different thing from expertise.
When Knowledge Becomes a Cage
Disciplines are useful. We need people who devote years to understanding medicine, law, education, psychology, biology, ecology, engineering, and countless other areas of human knowledge. The problem is not expertise. The problem arises when the boundaries around expertise become so rigid that information outside the accepted framework can no longer enter.
Professional education teaches not only information but a way of seeing. It teaches which questions matter, what language should be used, what evidence counts, which authorities are credible, and how a problem should be framed. Professional associations, accreditation, licensing, standards of practice, journals, and institutional cultures reinforce those frameworks.
These structures do more than organize professional knowledge and practice. They can also establish and maintain the boundaries around what the profession recognizes as legitimate knowledge, who is authorized to speak with expertise, and which ideas remain outside the accepted frame.
Over time, this can create a remarkably strong and self-reinforcing container around a particular way of knowing.
If everyone inside the container has been trained through similar assumptions, reads much of the same literature, speaks the same professional language, and is evaluated according to standards created largely within the same professional world, it becomes increasingly difficult to recognize what the framework itself may be unable to see.
The cage becomes invisible precisely because everyone inside it recognizes the same walls as reality.
This becomes particularly consequential when professional knowledge carries the authority to make decisions about other human beings. A specialized way of knowing can quietly become something larger—the power to define what another person's experience means, which knowledge deserves credibility, and which possibilities can be dismissed before they have genuinely been explored.
And this is not only a problem for professionals. We all do it. We create our own cages whenever we hold so tightly to a belief that something outside it can no longer reach us.
The Courage to Look Outside
Perhaps freedom begins with recognizing the cage.
What beliefs have I inherited without examining them? Whose authority have I accepted without asking what lies beneath it? What have I dismissed because it did not fit what I already believed? What might become visible if I stepped outside the framework through which I have always looked?
These questions do not require us to abandon knowledge, evidence, expertise, or discernment. Quite the opposite. They ask us to become more responsible for how we know what we believe we know. They ask us to become curious again.
The garden teaches this effortlessly. Nothing there needs to defend a theory of itself. Life responds, adapts, exchanges, changes, dies, returns, and grows through relationship. The whole is continually informing the parts, and the parts are continually changing the whole.
Perhaps we need more of that movement in ourselves and in the systems we create. More room for feedback. More room for contradiction. More room for another way of seeing. More willingness to discover that the boundary we thought marked the edge of reality was simply the edge of our own understanding.
The street art I photographed in Minneapolis offered the invitation in a single word:
UNLOCK.
Perhaps that is the work before us. To notice the invisible structures that confine thought. To loosen our grip on stories that no longer correspond with reality. To allow knowledge to remain in relationship with curiosity, and expertise in relationship with humility.
And then, like stepping out into the garden after a very long winter, to discover how much more of the world was there all along.
References
Gordon, L. R. (2006). Disciplinary decadence: Living thought in trying times. Paradigm Publishers.
Hofer, B. K., & Pintrich, P. R. (Eds.). (2002). Personal epistemology: The psychology of beliefs about knowledge and knowing. Routledge.
Varela, F. J. (1976). Not one, not two. CoEvolution Quarterly, 12, 62–67.
Photo Credit: P. Nerad