Stories shape the world we live in. They help us understand who we are, what has happened to us, where we belong, and how we make meaning of our lives. Some stories nourish us, help us grow, and allow us to find ourselves within their pages. Others are written for us—imposed through the interpretations of people or institutions that possess the authority to make their version of events matter more than our own.
I have lived inside a story that was not of my own making. It was written through forms and affidavits, medical records and legal documents, professional interpretations and clinical language that gradually acquired more authority than my own account of what had happened. My name was there, but the person described within those records was someone I did not recognize.
That experience changed forever the way I think about the power of story. The important question is not simply whether stories shape reality. Of course they do. The deeper question is: Who has the authority to write the story that others will come to believe?
When Repetition Becomes Reality
Perhaps one of the clearest examples can be found in the story our culture has been told about mental illness.
DSM-III, published in 1980, marked a major change in American psychiatric classification. We are now forty-six years beyond its publication. Within the increasingly medicalized understanding of emotional and psychological distress that followed, the idea that depression and other forms of mental distress resulted from a “biochemical disorder of the brain,” popularly expressed as a “chemical imbalance,” became deeply embedded in American culture.
Direct-to-consumer advertising helped carry that story far beyond psychiatry and the physician's office and directly into people's homes. Prescription-drug advertising was appearing on American television in the 1980s, and regulatory changes in the late 1990s helped usher in the era of pharmaceutical advertising with which we are now so familiar.
Those advertisements did more than market particular medications. They also helped teach the public a particular explanation for suffering: emotional distress could be understood as evidence of an underlying biochemical problem for which medication offered a corresponding chemical correction.
Repeated through advertising, professional language, patient education, media, and ordinary conversation, the explanation became so familiar that many people came to experience it not as one theory about mental distress, but as established scientific fact.
Yet the straightforward chemical-imbalance explanation that became embedded in popular culture has not been established by decades of research in the simple form in which it was so often presented.
That does not mean human suffering is unreal, nor does it resolve whether a particular medication may help a particular person. It raises a different question central to this essay: How does an explanation that remains scientifically unsettled become culturally experienced as settled fact?
Repetition matters. Authority matters. Marketing matters. Institutional legitimacy matters. A story can begin as theory, metaphor, hypothesis, simplification, or marketing language and, as it travels from one authoritative source to another, gradually lose its uncertainty. Eventually, we remember the conclusion while forgetting how we came to believe it.
And what happens across a culture can also happen to a single human being.
We Are All Storytellers
Every profession has its own way of telling a story. A police officer writes a report. A nurse enters notes into a medical chart. A physician records a history and assessment. A psychiatrist assigns a diagnosis and writes an evaluation. Attorneys construct stories through pleadings, briefs, evidence, and testimony. Judges ultimately write findings of fact, conclusions of law, and orders.
Each profession has its own language, conventions, assumptions, and forms through which lived experience is translated into something the profession recognizes. This does not make professional records inherently false. We need records. We need ways of communicating information across people, professions, and institutions.
But a record is not the event itself. It is a story about the event.
That distinction matters because professional stories do not necessarily remain separate from one another. One story can become the source material for the next. A police report may enter a medical record. Information in the medical record may be incorporated into a psychiatric evaluation. The evaluation may enter a legal proceeding. Attorneys draw from the accumulating record as they construct their arguments, and eventually a judge may be asked to make findings of fact from the information that has survived the journey.
With every telling, something may be selected, emphasized, interpreted, repeated, or left behind. Eventually, what appears to be information coming from several different places may trace back to the same original source. The repetition gives the story weight, while its point of origin becomes increasingly difficult to see.
Repetition begins to resemble corroboration.
This is one of the central problems I explored in my doctoral work. Stories do not simply describe reality. Once they enter systems of authority, they can begin organizing the way subsequent reality is perceived.
When the Form Becomes the Story
Forms are part of this process too. A professional form gives structure to information. It tells the person completing it what matters, what questions should be asked, where particular information belongs, and how the resulting account should be organized. That can be enormously useful. But a completed form can also acquire an appearance of completeness simply because every space has been filled.
A report looks official because it follows the expected format. A medical chart looks authoritative because it is a medical chart. A judicial order carries the authority of the court and may contain sections called Findings of Fact.
Yet the form can contain only what was placed within it. It cannot show us the question that was never asked, the information that was never investigated, the person who was never consulted, the context that disappeared during translation, or the contradictory information that never entered the record.
The form itself does not tell us whether the underlying responsibility was fulfilled. This is where story and reality can quietly begin to separate. The professional story may become increasingly polished and authoritative while the living person—or the original event it was intended to describe—becomes increasingly difficult to see.
The map begins replacing the territory. The story begins replacing the Real.
When the Story Becomes an Identity
This process becomes particularly consequential in psychiatry because the story may not remain merely something written about a person. It can become a diagnosis through which the person is subsequently understood.
There is something profoundly disorienting about reading an official description of yourself and discovering that the person on the page bears little resemblance to the person you know yourself to be.
Once a diagnostic story has been established, later words and actions may be interpreted through it. Agreement may be understood as insight, while disagreement can sometimes be interpreted as denial, confusion, or lack of insight. The person's response to the story is then understood through the story itself.
The circle becomes difficult to escape.
This is where institutional authority can become something more: the authority to determine which story will count as reality. And that raises an important question for every profession, not only psychiatry:
How does the person whose life is being described remain present in the story being written about them?
Reclaiming the Power of Story
This is one reason I write. I do not write because I believe my story should simply replace another and become the next unquestioned account. I write because reality must always remain capable of entering the conversation.
There is also something deeper at stake than what we often call “lived experience.” The person being observed, evaluated, diagnosed, represented, or judged does not arrive as an empty vessel possessing only an experience for professionals to interpret. That person brings an entire lifetime of knowledge with them—their education, work, relationships, history, culture, body, values, expertise, observations, and accumulated understanding of their own life and the world around them.
Yet we have constructed extraordinary authority around particular professions. Credentials and institutional roles can confer enormous epistemic weight upon the professional while quietly diminishing the knowledge of the person who has become the subject of professional attention. That authority is further reinforced by systems of professional self-regulation through which professions participate in defining their own standards, determining who is qualified to practice, evaluating professional conduct, and disciplining their own members.
This creates a kind of institutional container around professional authority that most people do not possess. The person under the microscope stands largely alone, while the professional stands not only as an individual but within a larger structure of credentials, licensing, professional standards, institutional affiliation, accepted practices, and the authority of the profession itself.
The person being observed, evaluated, diagnosed, represented, or judged does not arrive as an empty vessel possessing only an experience for professionals to interpret. That person brings an entire lifetime of knowledge with them—their education, work, relationships, history, culture, body, values, expertise, observations, and accumulated understanding of their own life and the world around them.
Yet once that person becomes the subject of professional attention, this wealth of knowledge can become strangely easy to override. The professional's specialized knowledge may be treated not simply as expertise within a particular domain, but as superior knowledge of the person herself.
That is an extraordinary transfer of authority, and one we rarely stop to examine.
And, we could rightly ask: Where does professional authority come from? How is it reinforced and regulated? What provides meaningful correction when the profession itself gets something wrong?
While professional knowledge and expertise matters, expertise is bounded. A psychiatrist may possess knowledge of the DSM categories and recommended drugs. An attorney possesses knowledge law and procedure. A physician possesses medical knowledge. A judge possesses knowledge of law and judicial process. None, by virtue of professional role alone, possesses complete knowledge of the human being before them or of every reality relevant to understanding that person's life.
This is why relationship matters. Knowledge should meet knowledge. Expertise should encounter experience, context, history, and the knowledge another person carries with curiosity rather than automatically superseding and/or overriding it.
When one form of knowledge is granted such extraordinary authority that other ways of knowing are no longer allowed to correct it, the problem becomes larger than disagreement. We have created a hierarchy in which the identity of the knower can determine whether knowledge itself is permitted to count.
Story can imprison in precisely this way. But story can also restore. It can recover what was omitted, return context to what was fragmented, preserve knowledge that an authorized account left outside the frame, and bring the person back into a story from which they had gradually disappeared.
Sometimes telling our own story is not simply an act of reclaiming voice. It is an act of reclaiming our standing as a knower.
And so the question remains: Who holds the pen that writes our reality?
Perhaps no one person, profession, institution, or authorized record should ever hold it alone. Truth asks something more difficult of us. It asks that we remain willing to listen, investigate, question, and allow the stories we have written—even those in which we have invested deeply—to be corrected by the reality they were intended to describe.